Background and
Objective: This is the
first course I am teaching at Knox College.
I taught for 10 years at the elementary level in first and second grade. I actually came up with the idea for this
course last winter. It is NOT a class for credit but I have been pleased with
my student attendance and enthusiasm. I want to provide a performance
assessment for creating a website that will reflect the process and the design
elements needed to create a navigable website.
I have begun by using a checklist of skills and components, and want to
develop a rubric after completing the assessment using the checklist. The checklist
is important for having students incorporate all the required components of the
assignment, but a rubric will better reflect their performance. Part of faculty development is developing
new assessments. This rubric will help
my future students understand their performance and will help me meet
professional goals as an instructor. In addition, I want to increase the use of
technology by using email and electronic transfer of documents for academic
purposes such as commenting on projects and commenting on quizzes.
Integrating web
design performance assessment and accompanying websites hosted by publishers: Creating a website with HTML is a skill that
can be marketed to potential employers and graduate schools. In addition to understanding how to create
websites, students will improve their ability to locate and access information
on the World Wide Web after researching various resources to include in their
websites. In addition to having an
understanding of how websites are created, students can use these skills for
creating web-based communication within different clubs and organizations on
campus.
Another experience
students have in some of their course work is taking quizzes on websites hosted
by textbook publishers. I wanted to experience this as an instructor and be
able to monitor students interacting with these sites.
Links to
Outcomes: Just as the Knox College addresses
technology standards for students in the college handbook, the State of
Illinois addresses technology in the Illinois Profession Teaching Standards.
“The Illinois Professional Teaching Standards should reflect the changing
resources available for teaching, such as technology and community options and
the new expectations for accountability and the accompanying need for an
understanding of assessment strategies.”
This understanding is important not only for teachers but for our future
workforce. The World Wide Web is one
resource available for teachers and increasing understanding of how it works
will help increase an individual’s ability to work critically and effectively.
Other Illinois
Professional Teaching standards addressed in creating a website are:
1M. Designs learning experiences and utilizes adaptive devices/technology
to provide access to general curricular content to individuals with
disabilities.
4E. Understands how to integrate technology into classroom instruction.
4H. Understands the uses of technology to address student needs.
5K. Uses strategies to create a smoothly functioning learning community in
which students assume
responsibility for themselves and one
another, participate in decision making, work collaboratively and
independently, use appropriate technology, and engage in purposeful learning
activities.
6N. Uses technology appropriately to accomplish instructional objectives.
8P. Uses technology appropriately in conducting assessments and
interpreting results.
9C. Understands school and work-based learning environments and the need
for collaboration with business organizations in the community.
Course Name:
Communication Using Technology
Section: CMPC001
Semester: Fall 01
Description:
Examine and develop effective communication skills through the use of computer
hardware and software applications. Topics include email and newsgroups, HTML,
Dreamweaver, Powerpoint, Pagemaker, On-Line library resources, Photoshop, and
web site evaluation techniques.
All course
documentation can be viewed at the following website
http://www.knox.edu/cmpc001
Requirements and
checklist under review: The
following are the guidelines I created for the final project for my
student. I want to create a website
developed by coding with HTML and hosted by the college webserver. I want to
revise the checklist after grading the student projects to make it encompass
the project and the other quiz related to web design. I would like to revise
the checklist to be a rubric rather than a checklist.
Personal Web
Pages--DUE NOVEMBER 6th by 1:00pm
Three types of text (bold, italic,
different size, different types of fonts)
Two links-must work
Two or more pages-must link to each other
Three images which relate to your topic
One Javascript or Applet
Insert one sound clip and/or one video
clip on at least one of your pages
Website
Checklist-Each component is worth 5 points
Name: Grade: /60 possible
|
Preparation |
Resources |
Navigation |
Media Use |
|
Planned time
wisely to assure access to server and software |
Used 5 internet
sites to gather information |
Organized ideas
in a meaningful way |
Words and images
easy to see-can be read in both browsers |
|
Made storyboard
to organize thoughts and ideas |
Cited resources
on separate page |
Balanced design
aspects with content |
Colors and
patterns compliment ideas and backgrounds |
|
Emailed and or
spoke with instructor with updates or questions |
Used material in
accordance with copyright |
Sought input from
instructor or classmates about design |
Titles and
heading are easy to distinguish from other text |
I also retyped the
following quiz from the textbook website to remove typographical errors and to
send it as an email attachment instead of receiving the results directly from
the publisher.
Read each statement. Use a drawing tool to Circle
TRUE if the statement is true and circle FALSE if the statement is not true. Attach your answers in an email addressed to
me by the due date and time. Be sure to
name your attachment using your username.
1.
As a result of the Internet, we now live in a global village.
TRUE
FALSE
2.
Generally, Internet connectivity is free.
TRUE
FALSE
3.
Communications over the Internet are built around the Transmission
Protocol Control/Internet Communications (TPC/IC).
TRUE
FALSE
4.
An e-mail Internet address consists of a user name and a host/network
identifier.
TRUE
FALSE
5.
The File Transfer Protocol (FTP) allows you to download and upload files
on the Internet.
TRUE
FALSE
6.
Anonymous FTP sites on the Internet have been outlawed.
TRUE
FALSE
7.
An Internet service provider (ISP) is any company that provides
individuals and organization with access to, or presence on, the Internet.
TRUE
FALSE
8. A
user location service may be used to search URLs for specific information.
TRUE
FALSE
9.
POP stands for both point-of-presence on the Internet and Post Office
Protocol.
TRUE
FALSE
10.
Gopher servers allow you to search by content rather than poking around
a hierarchy of menus to find the information you need.
TRUE
FALSE
11.
Hyperlinks encompass hypertext links and any multimedia object.
TRUE
FALSE
12.
Compared to other productivity tools, browsers are difficult to use.
TRUE
FALSE
13.
Searching and browsing on the Internet are the same thing.
TRUE
FALSE
14. Currently anyone wanting to register a
domain name on the Internet must do so through a government agency called
InterNIC.
TRUE
FALSE
15.
Another name for listserv is USENET.
TRUE
FALSE
KWL
Questions |
Knowledge |
Want to learn |
What I LEARNED |
|
What are the technology standards expected to be met by graduation? |
from the Knox catalog 2001-2001 (*see below) |
What is the best way to meet these standards even though they are not required for graduation? |
The standards in the handbook are only a guideline. All technology skills are integrated into coursework and computer center training workshops. Paper postings on department boards and email announcements of trainings were effective in increasing attendance for students and for faculty requesting training for classes. In addition, I have begun work with Residential Learning in order to integrate more email and network training into Orientation Week. |
|
What software applications are often used by faculty to assess students? |
Excel Pagemaker HTML coding SPSS Kaleidagraph Various on-line labs such as the Fly Lab |
Charts-how to make data into various chart Pagemaker-good design HTML-music and video integration into web pages |
I need additional work on converting checklists into rubrics. I can create guidelines and give effective feedback in a timely manner but need to pay attention to create effective rubrics. Another item is that Powerpoint is also used frequently in oral presentations on and off campus. The Sciences and the Anthropology/Sociology departments all have courses which require this software for reporting research findings. Next term, additional training sessions will be held on this application. |
|
What type of hardware is available to students? |
4 labs on campus-pcs and macs scanners, printers-color and bw, projection in 8 classrooms home accounts on server email accounts on server web accounts on server for individuals and students groups |
Lab image and Windows 2000-what are the some of the new security features for lab sign in with Windows 2000 |
In addition to lab machines, students organizations may also purchase hardware for use in student offices. For example, the student newspaper has 5 computers, 3 scanners, and two digital cameras for their exclusive use. These machines have access to all college owned software and are serviced and maintained by the college computer center. There is an email quota of 5mb and home account quota of 15mb. Students will receive an email message from the Help Desk when they reach 90% of quota and the students can come in and get help or talk over the phone on how to delete items. |
|
What technology support is available to students, staff, and faculty? |
Help Desk-8-6 M-F Lab assistants Computer Center-User Services Specialists/technicians Faculty/department support staff members |
Where will users go for their first help? Will they call the Help Desk or try to track down members of the computer center or ask a colleague? |
Faculty and staff use the Help Desk 60% of the time and students phone 40% of the time. Many faculty and staff phone the computer center directly with requests for hardware, software, or training schedules. Students usually go to another students with questions and then to the lab assistants. The lab manager suggests this is because students usually work late at night and are their own best resources at that time. |
|
Which software and hardware do I need training for improvement in troubleshooting skills? |
Need experience with Filemaker Pro and iCal web-based calendar |
Filemaker-how to create fields and create new layouts Calendar-how to import/export other calendar programs like Palm calendars and Outlook |
Now able to Create Fields and Define Value Lists in Filemaker. Helped create an internship database for career services office. Tried but not successful with import of iCal calendar to Outlook Express. Will continue to try to find solutions to this integration but may have Outlook removed as option due to virus problems. Gave workshop to Admissions office on iCal calendar and had positive feedback and individuals are using the electronic, webbased calendars. |
|
What fair use policies are in place? |
New revision of document exists-find a copy and speak to Dean for clarification of any items. |
What is my role with the distribution and adherence of users to this document. |
Knox College Policy on Acceptable Use of Information Technology Resources-Written Version 28 September 2001. I am now aware that this document exists and was distributed to faculty and staff by the Dean of the College. The document includes Guidelines, Information Disclaimer, Privacy and Enforcement items. My role is to have a copy of the document to understand how it affects me as a staff member. |
*Page 23 of the Knox College Catalog 2001-2001
Knox College students learn and apply computer-based information technologies as an integral part of their education. By developing these skills in all academic disciplines, students acquire the ability to adapt to continuously evolving technologies and information resources in various formats.
Essential skills include:
· familiarity with at least one of the standard operating systems (Windows and MAcintosh systems are commonly used and supported throughout the campus)
· work processing techniques, including document formatting and editing
· use of the campus network and e-mail system to store and transmit documents
· ability to effectively locate, assess, and use information resources on the World Wide Web
· ability to use the campus on-line library catalog, as well as digital indexes and full-text resources licensed by the library
The Computer Center and Seymour Library regularly provide assistance to students with basic skills.
In addition, some courses have specific information and educational technology needs, such as:
· presentation software
· spreadsheets
· statistical packages
· graphics design programs and packages
· mathematical programs
In cases in which specialized technology is used for a course, a combination or in-class instruction, library instruction, and Computer Center support enables students to develop the necessary skills.
Curriculum
Map
|
|
September 2001 |
October 2001 |
November 2001 |
|
Content |
Readings: Long and Long Computers: Information Technology in Perspective/9e Chapter 1 How local and worldwide computer networks impact businesses and society. Chapter 2 The function and applications of word processing software, presentation software, spreadsheet software, and database software. Chapter 3 The function of and relationships between the internal components of a personal computer, including the motherboard, processor, RAM and other memories, ports, buses, expansion boards, and PC cards. |
Readings: Long and Long Computers: Information Technology in Perspective/9e Chapter 6 How the application of the concept of connectivity is affecting your life. Chapter 7 How you can use Internet browsers to access a wealth of information on the Internet. Chapter 8 Approaches, considerations, and techniques associated with the design and publishing of Web sites. |
Readings: Long and Long Computers: Information Technology in Perspective/9e Chapter 9 Considerations critical to evaluating important ethical questions in the use of information technology. Chapter 10 Essential concepts plus an overview of popular software in these areas: graphics and multimedia, personal information management, home and family, education and edutainment, reference, and business and management. |
|
Skills |
*familiarity with at least one of the standard operating systems * word
processing techniques, including document formatting and editing *use of the campus network and e-mail system to store and transmit documents |
*ability to effectively locate, assess, and use information resources on the World Wide Web * use of the campus network and e-mail system to store and transmit documents and publish personal or group website |
*locate, identify, and discuss issues related to ethics and technology *becoming a savvy consumer-identify effective and affordable personal software |
|
Assessment |
*Create own History of the computer item with text and graphic *Chapter 1 vocabulary search puzzle or True/false test *Drawing of back of the computer with items labeled *multiple choice tests *Internet search activity for info on databases and spreadsheets |
*Code personal website using HTML coding and storing correctly on the campus network *Chapter 6 multiple choice and true/false test *Story board hard copy of personal website *Chapter 7 online search-choosing an ISP and what is Netiquette *Chapter 8 online search for web development tools and websites with good design elements present |
*Chapter 9-short answer essay questions *Chapter 10-Matching quiz |
|
Illinois Professional Teacher Standards (See below for full description) |
1M, 4E, 5K, 6N, 8P, 4H |
1M,4E, 5K, 6N, 9C, 8P |
4E, 5K, 9C, 1M, 8P, 6N, 4H, 5K |
1M. Designs learning experiences and utilizes adaptive devices/technology
to provide access to general curricular content to individuals with
disabilities.
4E. Understands how to integrate technology into classroom instruction.
4H. Understands the uses of technology to address student needs.
5K. Uses strategies to create a smoothly functioning learning community in
which students assume
responsibility for themselves and one
another, participate in decision making, work collaboratively and
independently, use appropriate technology, and engage in purposeful learning
activities.
6N. Uses technology appropriately to accomplish instructional objectives.
8P. Uses technology appropriately in conducting assessments and
interpreting results.
9C. Understands school and work-based learning environments and the need
for collaboration with business organizations in the community.
These would be the standards from the college catalog—note that these are not required for graduation
Page 23 of the Knox College Catalog 2001-2001
Knox
College students learn and apply computer-based information technologies as an
integral part of their education. By developing these skills in all academic
disciplines, students acquire the ability to adapt to continuously evolving
technologies and information resources in various formats.
Essential
skills include:
·
familiarity
with at least one of the standard operating systems (Windows and MAcintosh
systems are commonly used and supported throughout the campus)
·
word
processing techniques, including document formatting and editing
·
use
of the campus network and e-mail system to store and transmit documents
·
ability
to effectively locate, assess, and use information resources on the World Wide
Web
·
ability
to use the campus on-line library catalog, as well as digital indexes and
full-text resources licensed by the library
The
Computer Center and Seymour Library regularly provide assistance to students
with basic skills.
In addition, some courses have specific
information and educational technology needs, such as:
·
presentation
software
·
spreadsheets
·
statistical
packages
·
graphics
design programs and packages
·
mathematical
programs
In
cases in which specialized technology is used for a course, a combination or
in-class instruction, library instruction, and Computer Center support enables
students to develop the necessary skills.
490ASA
Mini-Project 2-Analysis of results
Revising a publisher’s quiz and developing a Website checklist were important steps to improving my skill in developing a rubric for a performance assessment of creating a website. Since this is the first time this type of course was offered, I had to look at the requirements in the college handbook for guidance about course content and look at how I am contacted for user support by both faculty and students. There was little student feedback, just a few basic comments of enjoying the class and having learned a lot about HTML and Pagemaker. In the report back from student evaluations (10 students responding), 100% of the students took the course just out of interest and 70% felt the overall quality of the course was Excellent or Good. Also, 60% felt exams and quizzes were Excellent or Good. Rewording and evaluating the quiz electronically was one way I integrated technology into my teaching. Many students check email late at night so this form of communication made by email helped meet their needs (IPTS 1M, 4E, 4H, 6N, 8P).
The Website checklist was handed out on paper to students two weeks prior to the assignment due date on the day HTML was introduced in class. Most students scored well in terms of finishing on time and in the design of their website. Only 2/11 students cited resources on a separate sheet but 11/11 did use material in accordance with copyright. Two students came and discussed with me about using an .mp3 file that was protected under copyright. Both decided that they did not want to contact the owner of the song in order to receive permission. I also discussed the use of .mp3 files with the reference librarians and the conclusion we reached was that we need to discuss it more and try to find definition of websites; if the World Wide Web is considered a public performance or avenue of redistribution. This demonstrated that students were willing to collaborate on the copyright issue and will are assuming responsibility for themselves in using technology appropriately (IPTS 9c and 5K**). Another outcome was that two students developed a separate website for campus organizations they belonged to that did not have a site. One was for the Senior Class to get information on meetings and events relating to seniors such as interviews in the Career Services office and photos from “senior-only” events. Another student developed a website for the Union Board which is in charge of scheduling lectures and other social events on campus for the entire campus community.
This willingness to use technology skills to enhance communication between student leaders and the student body demonstrated an understanding of adapting a frequently used media,websites, to provide additional access to information useful to students. Students live in different part of campus, but the campus network and connection to the World Wide Web is one resource they all use almost daily. Integrating this technology for use with student organizations is a responsible, logical addition to improve campus wide communication (IPTS 1M, 4E, 4H, 6N, and 8P**).
**1M. Designs learning experiences and utilizes adaptive devices/technology
to provide access to general curricular content to individuals with
disabilities.
4E. Understands how to integrate technology into classroom instruction.
4H. Understands the uses of technology to address student needs.
5K. Uses strategies to create a smoothly functioning learning community in
which students assume responsibility for themselves and one another,
participate in decision making, work collaboratively and independently, use
appropriate technology, and engage in purposeful learning activities.
6N. Uses technology appropriately to accomplish instructional objectives.
8P. Uses technology appropriately in conducting assessments and
interpreting results.
9C. Understands school and work-based learning
environments and the need for collaboration with business organizations in the
community.
Illinois Professional Teaching Standards (IPTS), Retrieved from the World Wide Web on November 27, 2001: http://www.isbe.state.il.us/.
After reviewing the website checklist and the IPTS, I developed the following rubric for use in the class next term. It is important to remember that the class is graded Pass/Fail so anyone not performing the website at a beginning level will fail the course. The question for research in the future will be to keep track of student progress using the performance rubric as well as implementation of websites with campus organizations, course work, and research.
Website Rubric
Name: Grade:
|
Preparation |
Resources |
Navigation |
Media Use |
|
Exemplary*Planned time wisely to assure access to server and software *Made storyboard to organize thoughts and ideas * Emailed and or spoke with instructor with updates
or questions |
Exemplary *Used at least 5 internet sites to gather information *Cited resources on separate page *Used material in accordance with copyright |
Exemplary *Organized ideas in a meaningful way *Balanced design aspects with content *Sought input from instructor and/or classmates about design |
Exemplary *Words and images easy to see-can be read in both browsers *Colors and patterns compliment ideas and backgrounds * Titles and heading are easy to distinguish from other
text |
|
Acceptable*Made storyboard to organize thoughts and ideas * Emailed and or spoke with instructor with updates or questions |
Acceptable *Used 3 internet sites to gather information *Used material in accordance with copyright |
Acceptable *Organized ideas in a meaningful way *Balanced design aspects with content |
Acceptable *Words and images easy to see-can be read in both browsers *Colors and patterns compliment ideas and backgrounds |
|
Beginning*Made storyboard to organize thoughts and ideas |
Beginning *Used 1 internet site to gather information |
Beginning *Organized ideas in a meaningful way |
Beginning *Words and images easy to see-can be read in both browsers |
|